Alternatives to turkey this Christmas: game birds and chicken (2024)

Features

by Malou Herkes

published on 6 November 2020

Alternatives to turkey this Christmas: game birds and chicken (1)

While most of us canget on board with atraditional Christmas turkey, if you have fewer guests to cater for or are worried about food waste, this might be the year to try something new and opt for a bird with smaller proportions. Thereare so many alternativesyou can choose from for a special Christmas centrepiece, particularly if you’re catering for a smaller crowd. Guinea fowl, pheasant, duck and quail – even a good old roast chicken will do the job.Here we’re sharing general guidance on cooking game birds and chicken, plus a selection of recipes to try.

Top tips for cooking game birds and chicken

1. Game birds, like pheasant and guinea fowl, are in season from September or Octoberthrough to January or February, so Christmas is a good time to enjoy them. Whether you’re cooking game or chicken, look out forwell-reared, free-ranging birds. They are available in most supermarkets.

2.Some birds come with thegiblets. Check inside the bird if they do, and remove them before cooking.Use giblets to make stock or gravy.

3. Don’t let it dry out! Birds have a tendancy to dry out when overcooked – from quail to chicken, their varying sizes mean that cooking times will vary widely too. Be sure to follow instructions carefully.

4.Bastingduring the cooking process will help keep the meat moist. Tilt the tin and use a spoon to scoop up some of the juices and drizzle it over.

4. Leave to rest after cooking, covered with tin foil and a couple of tea towels so it stays warm.

Game bird and chicken recipes to try

Allspice Honey Duck with Chicory, Orange and Pomegranate Salad

by Ainsley Harriott

from Ainsley’s Good Mood Food

If you’re swapping the big family meal for a romantic dinner for two this Christmas, you can’t do much better than Ainsley Harriott’s brightly flavoured dish of succulent duck and tangy pomegranate. This recipe feeds two.

From the book

Ainsley’s Good Mood Food

Claudia Roden’s Roast Chicken with Bulgur, Raisins, Chestnuts and Pine Nuts

by Claudia Roden

from Med

Inspired by the flavours of Turkey and the Arab world, Claudia Roden’s roast chicken is served on a bed of bulgur pilaf, studded with raisins and chestnuts. A zesty yoghurt sauce lifts an enhances the sweet, spiced flavours of this dish. This recipe serves four to six people.

From the book

Med

Quail with Caramelized Onions and Brandy (codorniz al brandy)

by Claudia Roden

from The Food of Spain

These tiny birds are full of flavour. Claudia Roden pairs them with slow-cooked onions, pan-braised together with brandyuntil the quail is beautifullytender and the onions deliciously sweet and caramelised. The key here is not to overcook quail– these birds requirejust 30 to 40 minutes and should still be slightly pink. Feeds two.

From the book

The Food of Spain

Buy Book

Guinea Fowl with Fennel

by Rose Gray, Ruth Rogers

from River Cafe Cook Book Easy

Guinea fowl has a mild gamey flavour, reminiscent of pheasant. This is a delicious way to serve it,cut into pieces and roasted all in one traywith fennel, pancetta and white wine.One bird feeds two people generously so keep that in mind if you want to scale up this recipe basedon how many mouths you have to feed. This recipe feeds four.

From the book

River Cafe Cook Book Easy

Buy Book

The Best Roast Chicken Ever

by Harry Eastwood

from The Skinny French Kitchen

“This recipe is what I would call the golden Mercedes of roast chickens”, says Harry Eastwood, and we couldn’t agree more. If you’re going to roast a chicken for Christmas, try this recipe with awild mushroom stuffing, flavoured with lemon, fresh herbs, lemongrass and garlic. Feeds four.

From the book

The Skinny French Kitchen

Buy Book

by Mary Berry

from Simple Comforts

Enriched with a tarragon butter and served alongside super soft onions, Mary’s take on a roast chicken has all the special touches your Christmas meal deserves but with none of the stress.

From the book

Simple Comforts

by Mary Berry

from Classic

With a delicious, complex flavour, this fatty bird is more able to stand up torobust flavours, like the classic cherry or orange sauces it’s often paired with. Try this cross betweenChinese crispy duck and a standard roast duck, withplenty of crisp skin andfall-apart moist and tender meat. Team it with asweet-savoury port and cherry sauce, and duck-fat roast potatoes. Mary also suggests saving the duck giblets to maketo make a flavoursome stock with the duck bones another day. Feeds four to six.

From the book

Classic

Jamie Oliver’s Roast Goose Slow-Cooked with Christmas Spices

by Jamie Oliver

from Jamie Oliver’s Christmas Cookbook

Jamie’s slow-cooked Christmas goose is brimming with festive flavours thanks to theblend of aromatic and warming spices used to coat the bird. Jamie also includesa brilliant get-ahead option for those of looking to prep early for the big day.

From the book

Jamie Oliver’s Christmas Cookbook

3-Bird Roast

by Tim Hayward

from Food DIY

“There’s a long historical tradition of show-off feasting dishes made by inserting progressively smaller animals into each other”, says Tim Hayward whose slightly more modest recipe cooks three birds – duck, chicken and pheasant –one inside the other.With a layer of sausage and chestnut stuffing, and a layer of sage stuffingbetween each bird, this really is a centrepiece to remember. Feeds eight with plenty of leftovers.

From the book

Food DIY

Buy Book

You might also like

View all

Recipe Collections

10 easy Indian vegetarian recipes

From moreish starters to hearty curries and centrepieces, find the best vegetarian Indian dishes you’ll want to make at home.

Recipe Collections

The best vegetarian burger recipes

From squeaky grilled halloumi to black bean, these are some of the very best vegetarian burger recipes.

Recipe Collections

Easy and authentic Mexican recipes

From vegetarian tacos to perfectly spiced chicken, find the best authentic Mexican recipes that you can easily recreate at home.

Alternatives to turkey this Christmas: game birds and chicken (23)

Subscribe to The Happy Foodie email newsletter

Get our latest recipes, features, book news and ebook deals straight to your inbox every week

Sign me up

Alternatives to turkey this Christmas: game birds and chicken (2024)

FAQs

What can I serve at Christmas instead of turkey? ›

Unique holiday dinner ideas
  • Beef Wellington: The Showstopper.
  • Christmas Roast Duck: The Twist on a Classic.
  • Vegetarian Enchiladas: The Surprise Favorite.
  • Roast Lamb: The Savory Star.
  • Stuffed Acorn Squash: The Festive & Flavorful.
  • Prime Rib Roast: The Hearty Hero.
Dec 12, 2022

What is an alternative to chicken or turkey? ›

Meat alternatives for chicken:
  • Ground turkey. Turkey meat is also rich in high-quality protein, which is why it is a good alternative for chicken. ...
  • Beef. There are a lot of recipes where you can easily replace chicken with beef. ...
  • Pork. Pork can also be a great substitute for chicken. ...
  • Lamb. ...
  • Processed meat. ...
  • Seitan. ...
  • Tofu. ...
  • Tempeh.
Jul 30, 2020

What are alternative birds to turkey? ›

Guinea fowl, pheasant, duck and quail – even a good old roast chicken will do the job. Here we're sharing general guidance on cooking game birds and chicken, plus a selection of recipes to try.

What is the best alternative turkey? ›

Alternatives to Thanksgiving Turkey
  • Goose. Another classic bird for special occasions is the goose. ...
  • Capon. Try roasting a capon, voted most popular poultry by Italian and French families who center their holidays around these tender, richly flavored birds. ...
  • Game Birds. ...
  • Ham. ...
  • Wagyu Beef. ...
  • Porcelet. ...
  • Lamb. ...
  • Venison.

What is a good meat for Christmas dinner? ›

Top 5 Traditional Meats For Christmas Dinner
  • Turkey. Let's admit it, a whole turkey is the best and most traditional meat for Christmas dinners. ...
  • Beef. Beef often comes to mind when choosing Christmas meats and for good reason. ...
  • Ham and Gammon. What's Christmas without a joint of ham? ...
  • Pork. ...
  • Lamb.

What meat is similar to turkey? ›

10 Main Course Alternatives to Turkey for Christmas
  • Duck. Another festive bird that offers flavorsome fat is duck. ...
  • Chicken. While chicken might not be the fanciest bird around, it can be a real crowd-pleaser and simple to prepare in a pinch. ...
  • Beef. ...
  • Venison. ...
  • Fish. ...
  • Pork. ...
  • Ham.
Dec 16, 2020

What can replace meat and chicken? ›

Meat Substitutes
  • Tofu. 1/10. Tofu is a plant-based choice that packs a protein punch -- half a cup has over 11 grams. ...
  • Tempeh. 2/10. Made from fermented soybeans, tempeh has even more protein than tofu. ...
  • Seitan. 3/10. ...
  • Jackfruit. 4/10. ...
  • Mushrooms. 5/10. ...
  • Beans. 6/10. ...
  • Textured Vegetable Protein. 7/10. ...
  • Chickpeas. 8/10.
Sep 28, 2023

What to eat if you don't like turkey? ›

20 Thanksgiving Dinner Alternatives
  • Pomegranate Cider Pork Loin with Rosemary Smashed Potatoes. ...
  • French Onion Chicken Lasagna Roll Ups. ...
  • My Mom's Chicken Marsala with Almond Green Beans. ...
  • Cacio e Pepe Pie. ...
  • Espresso Crusted Beef Tenderloin with Truffle Risotto. ...
  • Cider Braised Pot Roast with Butternut Squash.
Nov 19, 2020

What is the best bird for Christmas dinner? ›

Free-Range Geese

As with Christmas co*ckerel, the Christmas Goose was enjoyed as a popular choice for a delicious Christmas meal up until the 16th Century, before the introduction of turkey. For an unadulterated Saxon Christmas, goose is the thing to eat. Everything they say about the crispy skin is true!

What animal is similar to turkey? ›

Similar SpeciesRing-necked Pheasant

Ring-necked Pheasants are smaller and more slender than Wild Turkeys, with a longer neck, longer tail, and shorter legs.

What is the best way to eat cornish hens? ›

Because of their small size, Cornish hens are perfect as a serving for one person or split in half when served with some delicious sides. I love pairing this easy roasted Cornish hen recipe with my Cinnamon Roasted Sweet Potatoes; Italian Oven Roasted Vegetables; or Brussels sprouts...

What is the most popular vegetarian alternative to turkey? ›

1. Burmese Tofu (aka Chickpea Flour Tofu) For an alternative to turkey that's mild in flavor and can be treated like any other protein, turn to Burmese tofu, which transforms chickpea flour, oil, and water into a sturdy tofu-like dish.

Can you substitute chicken for turkey? ›

A whole chicken makes the perfect turkey substitute. To make it extra special, try this recipe for Parmesan Crusted Garlic Butter Chicken with Cauliflower!

Is turkey or ham better for Christmas dinner? ›

Overall, turkey is recommended over ham for nutrition. However, this is based on sodium content. Ham is very high in sodium, but it is rich in zinc, potassium, and iron. Ham has been used for generations to add salt and flavor to other dishes.

What is an alternative to a traditional Thanksgiving dinner? ›

Roast chicken or cornish hens - A whole chicken or a few hens can feed a crowd for less cost than a turkey. Roast with potatoes, carrots, and onions for a homey meal. Lasagna - Make an oversized lasagna with a meat sauce or go meatless. Add a salad and garlic bread for a satisfying Italian-style feast.

What is a traditional Italian Christmas dinner menu? ›

In Northern Italy, Lasagne Bolognese and filled pasta like manicotti and ravioli are traditional Christmas fare. Next comes the main event, the meat. Roasted veal, baked chicken, sausages or braised beef are common Natale entrées worth celebrating.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5585

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.