- Report this article
Harendra Pathak (हरेंद्र पाठक) 
Harendra Pathak (हरेंद्र पाठक)
Empowering software careers with 20+ meaningful years of industry wisdom ⊚ Ex-[Microsoft, Adobe & Flipkart] ⊚ Caltech, Cornell & IIT
Published Feb 26, 2023
+ Follow
Spotify model or the Agile at Scale model was introduced by Spotify as a way to address the challenges that come with scaling Agile beyond a few teams. However, despite its popularity and initial success, the model has also faced some criticism and failures. Here are some reasons why the Spotify model failed:
- Lack of contextualization:The Spotify model was designed to work for Spotify, based on its unique culture, structure, and business objectives. However, other organizations tried to apply the model without contextualizing it to their own needs and environment. This lack of contextualization often led to confusion, inefficiencies, and failure. It is essential to understand that every organization has unique needs, goals, culture, and structure that require a tailored approach. While the Spotify model can be an excellent source of inspiration, organizations should avoid blindly copying it and should instead focus on adapting it to their own context.
- Too complex:The Spotify model is a complex and intricate framework that involves multiple teams, tribes, chapters, and guilds. It requires a high level of coordination, collaboration, and communication, which can be difficult to achieve, especially for smaller organizations or those with less experienced teams. While complexity can be beneficial for larger organizations with mature Agile practices, it can be overwhelming and confusing for others. Therefore, organizations should carefully assess their level of maturity, complexity, and needs before deciding to adopt the Spotify model.
- Not Agile enough:Despite its name, the Spotify model has been criticized for not being Agile enough. Some experts argue that the model is too rigid, bureaucratic, and hierarchical, which goes against Agile values and principles. This can lead to a lack of innovation, creativity, and responsiveness. The Spotify model's focus on roles, processes, and rituals can sometimes overshadow the Agile values of individuals, interactions, and outcomes. Therefore, organizations should ensure that they strike a balance between structure and flexibility, processes and people, and roles and responsibilities.
- Resistance to change:The Spotify model requires a significant shift in organizational culture, structure, and mindset, which can be challenging to achieve. Some teams and individuals may resist the change, leading to a lack of buy-in, engagement, and adoption. Changing the way an organization works requires more than just adopting a new framework. It requires a deep understanding of the organization's culture, values, and beliefs, as well as strong leadership, communication, and collaboration skills. Therefore, organizations should invest in change management, training, and coaching programs to ensure a smooth transition to the Spotify model.
- Misalignment with business goals:The Spotify model focuses primarily on improving the efficiency and effectiveness of software development and delivery. However, it may not align well with the broader business goals and objectives, leading to a lack of strategic alignment and impact. Organizations should ensure that they align their Agile practices with their overall business strategy and objectives, ensuring that they deliver value to their customers and stakeholders.
In conclusion, the Spotify model has faced some criticism and failures due to its lack of contextualization, complexity, rigidity, resistance to change, and misalignment with business goals. However, it is important to note that the model can still be successful if implemented and adapted correctly, based on the organization's needs and environment. Organizations should focus on understanding their unique context, assessing their level of maturity and complexity, striking a balance between structure and flexibility, investing in change management and coaching, and aligning their Agile practices with their overall business goals and objectives. By doing so, they can unlock the full potential of the Spotify model and achieve their desired outcomes.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
18
2 Comments
Marco Derksen
Digitaal strateeg, docent en ondernemer
8mo
- Report this comment
Who actually came up with "The Spotify model"? Was this something by Spoty itself, and if so, where can I find it? Or is this a term coined by companies that followed Spotify's lead in organizing themselves differently? Think of ING in the Netherlands.
1Reaction
See more comments
To view or add a comment, sign in
More articles by this author
No more previous content
- The Eight Fallacies of Distributed Computing Mar 19, 2023
No more next content
Sign in
Stay updated on your professional world
Sign in
By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.
New to LinkedIn? Join now
Insights from the community
- Team Management How can you use the Spotify model to manage self-managed teams?
- Agile Methodologies What is the Spotify model for Agile scaling and how can you use it?
- Process Design What are some successful examples of change management in automated processes?
- Product Management How do you stay inspired by the latest trends in product management?
- Product Management You’re a new manager in product management. How can you lead your team to success?
- Startup Development What are the most effective ways to encourage product team ownership of the roadmap and strategy?
- Product Management What are the best ways to lead a Product team on a tight budget?
- Product Management As a product manager, how can you stay adaptable and keep up with industry trends?
- Product Management What do you do if your executive role in Product Management lacks innovation and creativity?
Others also viewed
- With 'Spotify Model', Is History Repeating Again? RAJESH Viswanathan 4y
- Why Copying Spotify's Squads and Tribes Model Probably Won’t Work for You Arif Harbott 3y
- We are learning to be Agile, the Spotify way ! Lalitha Vishali Pannala 8y
- Spotify vs. SAFe, "Enemies" or "Undercover Marriage"? Hào Lǐ 1y
- Why Spotify Squads Are a Popular Failure for Product Teams Chameleon 1y
- If you meet the Spotify Model on the road, kill the Spotify Model. Dave S. 4y
- Thoughtful Delivery©- The Need Anil Appukuttan 4y
- Are we really improvising Agile? Megha Gupta 5y
- The Spotify Model: A Symphony of Agile Scaling, Autonomy, and Continuous Improvement Althris Training 6mo
- From Accenture to Spotify: the magic of agile multidisciplinary teams Eric VIARDOT 4y
Explore topics
- Sales
- Marketing
- Business Administration
- HR Management
- Content Management
- Engineering
- Soft Skills
- See All
